6 Out of 10

★ ★ ½
2.5 Stars
It's true that everyone is their own worst critic, and in McKinnon Powell’s 6 Out of 10, a lifetime pursuit of perfection is condensed into a multimedia exploration of the shapes we twist into in order to feel like we are enough.
Powell takes us through his personal timeline, beginning with a conservative upbringing and a childhood shadowed by intrafamilial sexual assault, grief, and poor self-image. As an adult, the struggling actor seeking--validation and acceptance from insecure men and a career built on rejection and criticism--tries everything from no-carb diets to a Jesus impersonator hairdo to achieve the perfect look but is haunted by the voices of his family, boyfriends, and directors who constantly remind him that he will never rise above being a solid 6.
A large projector screen sets the scene for Powell’s story, shifting between childhood photos, scene settings, uncanny artificial renderings of the perfect body, and mock news reports. The rippling effect of globally significant events including the Pulse nightclub shooting, the AIDS epidemic, and the 2016 election are internalized through Powell’s memoir, impacting and often producing interpersonal conflicts wherein he stays silent and sets aside his values in order to feel accepted.
The piece resolves with a determination to break from the lifelong cycle of shame and externalized self-worth. The mirror is shattered, beauty is found in the imperfections, and Powell declares: “I don’t do numbers anymore.”
6 Out of 10 is a heartfelt and courageously honest reflection, but leaves something to be desired in performance. The phrase “show, don’t tell” comes to mind, and unfortunately I felt that this piece did not escape this common pitfall of autobiographical storytelling wherein the intended message and impact of each moment is spelled out for the audience.
Despite the personal nature of 6 Out of 10 Powell did not engage with the audience. As for pacing, though there were some top-notch impressions of devout Southern grandmas and whimsically harsh directors, comedy gave way jarringly to depictions of trauma and abuse before trust could be built with the audience.
That being said, the irony of critiquing a show whose premise is built on breaking free from others' judgments and ratings is not lost on me, and I both applaud the bravery and self expression within this piece. I wholeheartedly agree that belonging starts from within and Powell carries this truth with his story.
6 Out of 10
Starring: McKinnon Powell
Performed on November 13, 2026
October 19 – November 22, 2026
Theatre Row, 410, West 42nd Street , in Manhattan
Reviewer: Ellie Guyon



Comments